Where to Eat on St. George Island
Oysters - Seafood - Burgers - Pizza - Ice Cream and More!
On St. George Island
The owners of St. George Island Cottage live on the island and love to go out and enjoy our local restaurants.
Here are our favorites!
Check out the links for menus and more information!
Paddy’s Raw Bar – Oysters, live music, good food and a fun atmosphere
Paddy's is a great spot for family fun, food and live music and events.
- Great feature: Live music nearly every night
- Favorite thing about it: We love the vibe at Paddy's and the friendly staff!
- What we order: Oysters, bang bang shrimp tacos, salads, buffalo shrimp wrap, burger
- Best value: The dinner salad topped with Mahi mahi or shrimp (or chicken if you don't eat seafood)
The Sand Bar - Family friendly, great food
The Sand Bar (Formerly Harry As) is reimagined and reinspired. It opened in May, 2026 with a bang! Great food, full bar, and an inviting, bright and fun decor quickly made it a favorite for locals and visitors alike
- Great feature: Very inviting space, airconditioned inside and a large court yard for events and bands
- Favorite thing about it: We love that the new owners revitalized the old Harry As and made it better than ever!
- What we order: pimento burger, crab bites, wings, salad
- Best value: The burgers and sandwiches
Blue Parrot – Beachfront dining with seafood and cocktails
- Great feature: SGI's only gulf-front bar and restaurant
- Favorite thing about it: The tiki bar
- What we order: mahi sandwich, cheese burger in parrot-dise, oyster po-boy
- Best value: burgers and sandwiches
BJ's Pizza- Good pizza, sandwiches and salads
- Great feature: Fast and good food.
- Favorite thing about it: Carryout or eat-in
- What we order: pizza, burger and fries, salads
- Best value: grilled chicken salad
The Beach Pit SGI – BBQ + seafood combo
- Great feature: Menu has something for everyone, from BBQ to seafood
- Favorite thing about it: only place that offers a full breakfast on SGI
- What we order: Rib plate, burger, grouper sandwich
- Best value: sandwiches
Ice Cream:
- Aunt Ebby's Ice Cream
- Coffee and Cream
Weber’s Little Donut Shop – A morning essential
They've created quite a demand for their home-made donuts. People stand in line for them.
Island Food Trucks:- BigFish SGI - Seafood
- El Corozal - Honduran
- Portside Pizza - Pizza
- Captains Corner - smash burgers and fried seafood
- Acai Bowls
- Crave - Donuts
- Mellow Mullet - Snow Cones
Island Seafood Vendors (offering fresh and frozen seafood):
- Captains Seafood
- Doug's Seafood